All Clad D3 vs D5 Cookware – Which One Will Suit Your Kitchen?


All-Clad cookware – the name itself is enough to spend your hard-earned money. It is an American brand that operates solely from Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, in the USA. It promises lifetime durability and top-notch performance on all its cookware collections; however, here we are going to review the two of its best picks in 2020: All Clad D3 vs All Clad D5.

I am going to touch each factor here, including design, construction, material, feature, performance, compatibility, versatility, warranty, and cost. But, before we compare all these factors, let’s take a quick look at each cookware set.

All Clad D3 vs D5: Let’s get started!

All Clad D3 vs All Clad D5: Full Reviews

All-Clad D3 Stainless Steel 10-Piece Cookware Set

Are you passionate about cooking delicious meals for your family and friends? This All-Clad D3 stainless steel cookware set is a timeless inclusion to your kitchen. It is known for its performance, construction, and ease of use. This 10-piece pots and pans are an ideal investment for your versatile cooking requirements – you can braise, sear, sauté, and simmer, all with this kitchenware set. Made in the USA, this cookware is born to last for a lifetime – it comes with a lifetime limited warranty.

This D3 stainless steel cookware set is made of triple alternating layers of conductive aluminum and American stainless steel – the construction sustains up to the rim. The handles of these pots and pans are secured with stainless steel rivets and follow the stay-cool technology for a comfortable grip. The set is compatible with preparing meals on all stovetops, including induction cooktops, broilers, and ovens with heat-tolerance of 600oF. The set also includes tight-fitting, flat stainless steel lids to retain all the meal’s nutrients and juices. This cookware is dishwasher-safe, making it easy to use, clean, and maintain.

All-Clad D5 Stainless Steel 10-Piece Cookware Set 

Are you a chef looking for a professional cookware set? This All-Clad D5 stainless steel cookware set is an ideal pick that offers your kitchen an immersive professional appeal. This set offers professional performance along with sturdy construction and long-lasting durability. It is an all-in-one cookware set for professional braising, searing, simmering, and sautéing, promising versatility in chef-style cooking. This cookware set brags about being manufactured in the USA and offers a lifetime limited warranty. 

This D5 stainless steel pots and pans are made of 5-ply alternating layers of impact-bonded aluminum and American stainless steel with construction straight up to the rim. The exteriors are brushed for an elegant stainless steel look. It offers excellent even heat distribution for speedy, wrap-free, and perfect cooking results. The pots and pans are designed with flared edges to deliver drip-free pouring experience. The stainless steel handles are long and riveted for a sturdy, comfortable grip. The set includes stainless steel covers, which allows the nutrients and flavors to remain intact. This cookware set offers 100% compatibility with all stovetops, ovens, and grills with a heating capacity of 600oF, and is dishwasher-safe.

All Clad D3 vs All Clad D5: Comparison Table

Major Features

All Clad D3

All Clad D5





3-ply heavy-duty aluminum and American stainless steel

5-ply brushed impact-bonded aluminum and American stainless steel





Yes (all cooktops)

Yes (all cooktops)


Yes (metal utensil-safe)

Yes (metal utensil-safe)





Yes (up to 600F)

Yes (up to 600F)

Dishwasher Safe




Riveted, stay-cool stainless steel handles

Riveted, stay-cool stainless steel handles


Flat, tight-fitting stainless-steel lids

Flat, tight-fitting stainless-steel lids

All Clad D3 vs All Clad D5: Detailed Comparison

All Clad D3 vs D5 Detailed Comparison Review

1. Design and Construction

Let’s talk about the design and construction here. The All Clad D3 and D5 offer similar design and construction; however, they are factors that differentiate them from each other. The All Clad D3 offers a simple stainless steel exterior; whereas, the All Clad D5 set offers a brushed stainless steel exterior. The former cookware set is designed for home kitchens; whereas, the latter pots and pans are designed for professional kitchens.

The All Clad D3 cookware is constructed with three alternating layers of heavy-duty aluminum and American stainless steel. In contrast, the All Clad D5 cookware is made of five alternating layers of impact-bonded aluminum and American stainless steel. Both the cookware sets are constructed for sturdy, long-lasting use and promise to perform for a lifetime.

PS: I am a home-chef, I love to cook for my family and support kitchenware buyers online; therefore, I pick the All Clad D3 stainless steel cookware set here.

2. Material and Durability

The All-Clad D3 cookware set is made of heavy-duty aluminum and American-originated stainless steel, while the All Clad D5 cookware is made of impact-bonded aluminum and American stainless steel. Yes, both are constructed using similar materials; however, the durability is distinct.

All Clad D5 is more durable than All Clad D3 – D5 has five layers bonded with each other, and D3 has three layers bonded together. D3 is built for everyday home-based cooking delight; while, D5 pots, and pans are designed to provide wrap-free professional cooking solutions.

PS: It’s hard to choose one of the two because they are similar in material and durability; however, All Clad D3 is good for me as far as my requirement is concerned.

3. Performance

The All-Clad D5 set is better performing than All-Clad D3 pans and pots – I’ll explain. The All Clad D3 cookware set is born to perform in home-kitchens, while the All Clad D5 cooking set is developed to perform in professional kitchens. Not only both the collections of pots and pans provide even heat distribution for perfect cooking, but it also leaves no hotspots behind. Both sets allow you to cook the best meals on low to medium heat. The handles are constructed for a comfortable grip, and the lids perfectly fit the pots and pans to ensure that the meal’s flavors, nutrients, and moisture remain within.

There’s are a few extras when we keenly look at the All Clad D5 cookware set – it provides 100% wrap-free cooking experience. Because of the brushed finish, the exterior remains stain-free, even the fingerprints don’t dirty the outer surface of the cookware. These sets are made of high-quality stainless steel exterior; therefore, they are scratch-resistant and corrosion-free.

PS: The All-Clad D5 stainless steel cookware set delivers better performance than All Clad D3 cookware. Even if I am going to use it for my home, I would prefer to use the All Clad D5 cookware set for best performance.

4. Cleaning and Maintenance

Both the cookware are dishwasher-safe; therefore, using, cleaning, and maintaining these sets is quick and convenient. In any case, if the food sticks on the surface, then you must mix stainless steel detergent, vinegar, and hot water. Dip the cookware inside the mixed liquid, and leave it for around 30 minutes. The stains, stuck food, and other unwanted remains will disappear.

PS: I would prefer to pick any one of them – but I still go with the performance-based cookware here. It is the All-Clad D5 stainless steel cookware set.

5. Cooktop Compatibility and Versatility

These cookware sets are extremely compatible and versatile. Both these cookware sets are compatible for use on all cooktops, including gas stoves, electric, ceramic, and glass cooktops, halogen, and induction stovetops. These sets are oven-safe and broiler-safe too – they can tolerate heat up to 600oF, which means you can cook all kinds of meals even in the highest oven and grill temperatures.

Both – All Clad D3 and D5 sets of pots and pans are extremely versatile – you can simmer, braise, sear, bake, and sauté in these cookware sets. You can call them an all-in-one cooking solution for your kitchen at home or at work. They are scratch-free; therefore, you can use all types of utensils – metal, wood, or nylon with these pots and pans. They are easy to store and handle; therefore, cooking in them becomes a bliss for us. What more can you ask for?

PS: I don’t know why, but my views are inclined towards the D5 cookware. Although I am not a professional chef, I still want to invest in the All Clad D5 cookware set.

6. Value for Money

These sets claim to perform for a lifetime and are manufactured in the USA. The brand – All-Clad offers a limited lifetime warranty with them. The difference in the cost between All Clad D3 and D5 cookware is negligible. Both offer high-end performance results; they are extremely durable. Both have lifetime warranties attached, and both are made in the USA, making the products highly reliable. The D5 has an extreme wrap-protection feature, which makes it stand out of the two we are reviewing here.

PS: I will choose All Clad D5 over D3 cookware set – D5 stainless steel cookware set is a complete value for money product, even if I have to pay a little more than All Clad D3 pots and pans.

Which Cookware Is Better: All Clad D3 or All Clad D5?

All Clad D3 vs D5 Review

After in-depth research on both All-Clad cookware collections and a detailed review of both sets, I have concluded that the All-Clad brushed D5 stainless steel 10-piece cookware set is the one I will choose. It not only has amazing features that I can enjoy both at home and work, but it is a complete value for money. It will last for years together for me.

I am definite about my choice; what about you?

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.